Independent Review Requirements: What South African Companies Must Know
Understanding Independent Review Requirements is crucial for any South African business that must comply with the legal framework governing financial reporting. In South Africa, these requirements are largely defined by the Companies Act No. 71 of 2008 and its associated regulations, which set out when an independent review of a company’s financial statements is required, who must perform such reviews, and the role these reviews play in corporate compliance.
🧾 What Is an Independent Review?
An independent review is a limited-assurance engagement where an independent professional (such as a registered auditor or accredited accountant) assesses a company’s annual financial statements to determine whether any material misstatements exist. Unlike a full audit, an independent review provides “negative assurance,” meaning the reviewer expresses that nothing has come to their attention that causes them to believe the statements are not presented fairly. (saica.org.za)
📊 Independent Review Requirements under the Companies Act
South African companies must determine whether their annual financial statements must be audited, independently reviewed, or if a simple compilation suffices. This determination depends primarily on a company’s Public Interest Score (PIS) and whether financial statements are prepared externally or internally. (Accounting Weekly)
Public Interest Score (PIS) is calculated based on:
- Number of employees
- Turnover (in R millions)
- Third-party liabilities
- Number of shareholders or members
A higher score generally triggers stricter assurance requirements. (saicawebprstorage.blob.core.windows.net)
📌 When an Independent Review Is Required
A company must undergo an independent review (instead of a full audit) when:
- Its PIS is 100 or more but less than 350, and its financial statements are compiled independently, not internally. (Accounting Weekly)
- Its PIS is below 100 and the company is not owner-managed (meaning shareholders are not active in management) and prepares internal financials. (Accounting Weekly)
If the PIS meets the threshold of 350 or above, a full audit is usually required instead of an independent review unless the company voluntarily opts for an audit. (Accounting Weekly)
📑 Who Can Perform an Independent Review?
The Companies Regulations, 2011 outline that reviews must be performed by qualified, independent professionals, and not by anyone directly involved in preparing the statements. For companies whose PIS is 100 or more, the reviewer must be a registered auditor or an accredited professional with a recognized body. For companies with a lower PIS, a broader range of qualified accountants may perform the review. (saicawebprstorage.blob.core.windows.net)
This ensures the review remains objective and independent of internal financial preparation. (saicawebprstorage.blob.core.windows.net)
📊 Independent Review vs. Audit
It’s important for business owners to distinguish between the two engagements:
- Audit: Provides reasonable assurance and includes extensive testing of controls and transactions.
- Independent Review: Offers limited assurance through inquiry and analytical procedures, checking for material misstatements without exhaustive verification. (RSM Global)
While both improve transparency and credibility, an independent review is generally less costly and less comprehensive than an audit. (RSM Global)
📌 Why Independent Reviews Matter
Compliance: Failing to meet independent review requirements under the Companies Act can lead to regulatory issues, including non-compliance with filing obligations at the Companies and Intellectual Property Commission (CIPC). (cipc.co.za)
Credibility: Independent reviews help build confidence with stakeholders, such as investors, banks, and potential partners, by confirming that financial statements are reliable. (Accounting Weekly)
Risk Management: Review engagements can highlight areas of financial misstatement or weakness in financial processes, helping companies address issues early. (saica.org.za)
Independent Review Requirements are a key part of South African corporate governance and financial reporting. By understanding when an independent review is required, and ensuring compliance with these statutory obligations, companies can maintain credibility, reduce risk, and operate within the legal framework defined by the Companies Act. (Accounting Weekly)
Leave a Reply